Eddie (Brad Garrett) and Joy (Joely Fisher) attend the 25th anniversary party of their neighbors Stan and Vicki (Jerry Lambert and Christine Dunford), even though they forgot to RSVP. Throughout the duration of the night, curiosity gets the best of them after they continue hearing about how well Stan takes care of Vicki. Following a conversation with his buddy Stan, Eddie returns to Joy with a fresh, new perspective about his marriage and their roles. Meanwhile, Steph (Kat Foster) can’t seem to convince Jeff (Eddie Kaye Thomas) to dance with her, so she insists on showing off her best dance moves to their neighbor Cofeld (Anthony Anderson).